The sound of one hand zen and christian spirituality notes, helsinki march 3, 2003 notto r. However, another koan presents a longer version, in which zhaozhou answered yes in response to the same question asked by a different monk. There is no clever answer that glibly puts the question to rest. If you meditate on koans enough, youll build it up just like a muscle. For clapping, two hands are needed, apparently opposed to each other but deep down creating a single. Although once hand clapping was written in the early 1960s its satiric message still rings true.
Either a onehand clapping makes a lighter sound than a twohand clapping when your one hand tries to slap its fingers to its palm. Thelle on the boundary the sound of one hand paul mccartney. A primary tool of zen teaching is the use of koans. Instead of the nowtainted by overuse whats the sound of one hand clapping, senzaki and cast present us with what are actually more poignant stories than what we normally think of as koans.
This book of koans contains some of the most important zen sayings of all time along with insightful commentary. Including koans that go back to the master who first brought the koan teaching. For all that, the sound of the one hand opens the door to zen like no other book. The book of householder koans book santa monica public. Viewed as an ideal method for attaining and transmitting an unimpeded experience of enlightenment, they became the main object of study in zen. Most people know the famous riddle, what is the sound of one hand clapping. A teacher of zen would reject them out of hand, all the while demanding a real response.
One hand clapping disambiguation this disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title the sound of one hand clapping. Jundo and kirk discuss the origin and history of koans, what they mean, how they work, and what the sound of one hand clapping really is. Koan work, like zen practice meditation, is a way of developing the skills of selfunderstanding and selfmastery in life. It is meant to test whether you have awakened to your bodhinature or whether you are still entrenched in your worldly mortal false self ego mindconsciousness caught up in the conventional world that is samsara and still tread. For instance, heres what happened when i meditated on the one hand clapping koan. With each page featuring a quote, phrase, story, koan, haiku, or poem, zen companion. Bart simpson, americas favorite animated smartaleck kid, replied to the famous question what is the sound of one hand clapping. The title one hand clapping is from a traditional zen koan, or unsolvable.
That a handbook existed recording not only the riddling koans that are central to zen teaching but also detailing the answers to them seemed to mark zen as rote, not revelatory. Zen koans, beginning some 1500 years ago, refer to stories or questions arising in encounters between monks and old chinese and japanese masters, and include commentaries designed to help the zen practitioner awaken. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The zen school of buddhism began in 7th century china, then spread to vietnam, korea, and japan. The sound of one hand clapping penguin books australia. About the book what is the sound of one hand clapping. It is absurd there cannot be any sound of one hand clapping. They are used as objects of meditation for developing insight and also as tests of whether a.
Many are also aware that it is connected with zen buddhism, and some will even know that it is a famous koan. The sound of one hand clapping the sound of one hand. And there is a sound permeating existence itself, which is not created. Never understood why people have a problem answeringwhat is the sound of one hand clapping. The other answer would be that it sounds like this. The word anahat means exactly the same as what zen people call the sound of one hand clapping. Ask around and youll find only a few people with this talent i am one.
Toyo saw the older disciples visit the masters room each morning and evening to receive instruction in sanzen or personal guidance in which they were given koans to stop mindwandering. By now, most of you probably know that the question is not a riddle. If an internal link led you here, you may wish to change the link to point directly to the. One hand clapping by serge kahili king there is a famous zen koan philosophical riddle which asks, what is the sound of one hand clapping. For all that, the sound of one hand clapping opens the door to zen like no other book. Koans are a great way to tap into your intuitive side. It is a mistake to think of a koan as a question that has an answer. This is a cd that will act out you even extra to pass thing. Its not in any zen buddhist manuscripts, but right there in the book of psalms. When the monk realizes that the koan is not merely an object of consciousness but is also he himself as the activity of seeking an answer to the koan. Masters of zen buddhism often give their more advanced students a koan to contemplate.
Thousands of classic koans emerged from the lives of monks living inside a chinese or japanese culture, and the commentaries on those koans contain poetic elements and images that have proved challenging for many westerners. But the koan about the one hand clapping is just an example of zen separation of the physical aspect the hands action from the mental aspect the hearing of sound. Two mice, one white and one black, little by little started to gnaw away the vine. One of the mostloved and biggest selling literary novels in australian history. One hand clapping is the story of janet and howard shirley, living a dreary life in the. There is another koan that i referred to in the first paragraph. Not only that, but youll learn more about the world around you. A famous example of koan is the statement listen to the sound of one hand clapping.
Zen koans by steven heine overdrive rakuten overdrive. This book supposedly reveals the secret answers behind the koans, those famous riddles of zen practice, such as what is the sound of one hand clapping. The master of kennin temple was mokurai, silent thunder. Koans are questions whose answer cannot be arrived at through analytical mental processes you cant think your way to. You cannot prove gods existence any more than you can mimic the sound of one hand clapping. The book of householder koans is a collection of koans created by 21 st century zen practitioners living a lay life in the west. The silence is where every noise goes back to and without the silence we wouldnt have sound. It is an example of destroying the truth of interconnectedness and nonduality of the process of producing the mental sense of hearing from the physical origin. The book was a rapid joy to write, a months worth of bricolage, for which. The purpose of koan is to help zen practitioners transcend the rational intellect and develop intuition. Zen was a secretive practice, its wisdom relayed from master to novice in strictest privacy.
We all have our own opinions of what various koans mean, and recently ive been going around asking folks what they thought of what is the sound of one hand clapping. This zen koan or paradoxical riddle, composed by the japanese zen master hakuin, has been the source of many interpretations with even bart simpson adding to the list of possible answers proceeding to close and open his hand quickly, thus creating a slight clapping sound at best. This is the ultimate koan on the power of living in the moment. The sound of one hand zen and christian spirituality. Of course, this koan is much easier to be tested on due to possibilities of acting it out, such as the one answer most common that we know, where the teacher holds out their hand, and you slap your hand into theirs, signifying both are one mind and using one hand to clap. The question often is shortened to what is the sound of one hand clapping. The student of zen is supposed to meditate on this riddle until some degree of insight or enlightenment occurs. Koans like hakuins what is the sound of one hand clapping. What is the sound of one hand clapping is a well known zen buddhist koan.
A koan is a riddle or puzzle that zen buddhists use during meditation this zen buddhist answered that riddle. He had a little protege named toyo who was only twelve years old. The australian booksellers association book of the year begins in 1954, in tasmania where bojan buloh brings his family to start a new life away from slovenias privations of war and refugee settlements. Buy the sound of one hand clapping reprints by richard flanagan isbn. Including koans that go back to the master who first brought the koan teaching method from china to japn in the eighteenth century, this book offers, in the words of the translator, editor, and zen initiate yoel hoffmann, the clearest, most detailed, and. The koans deal with the challenges of relationships, raising children, work, money, love, loss. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the sound of the one hand. Zen emphasizes direct experience and enlightenment in contrast to rote learning of classical texts. About this episode youve probably heard about koans, those enigmatic zen dialogs that make no sense. While it seeks neither to define zen nor answer its most famous koan a riddle unanswerable by conventional thinking, in this case the sound of one hand clapping, this bestselling little book with 437,000 copies in print possesses a maverick zen spirit that points to a different way of looking at the world. The question, what is the sound of one hand clapping. When the sound of the one hand came out in japan in 1916 it caused a scandal.
One hand clapping is a short, bitterly humorous look at a british workingclass couple who strive to win a fortune on a tv quiz show, then spend their fortune in a rather peculiar fashion. When i asked my father the koan, we got into an interesting existential conversation about what is and the nature of the universe. His first, death of a river guide 1994, was shortlisted for the miles franklin award, as were his next two, the sound of one hand clapping 1997 and goulds book of fish 2001. Explanatory words such as the two hands represent duality, the one hand is unity or the sound of one hand is the sound of the true self are useless. The sound of one hand clapping tao sangha north america. In the early fifties, this zen koan may well have had a glow of mysticism that has since been lost in the mists of. The book of householder koans waking up in the land of attachments book. Grasping the vine with one hand, he plucked the strawberry with the other. The spaces inbetween the notes along with the notes create music. As mortal beings we are constantly surrounded by death. These cryptic expressions are among the bestknown examples of koans, the confusing, often contradictory sayings that form the centerpiece of zen buddhist learning and training.
166 1582 1607 1528 1189 89 1348 1180 1563 1425 11 1184 300 661 1619 1444 30 261 754 285 1399 138 542 547 1175 1060 527 1341 1028 1425 431