The men on the ground after the bloody deed took an oath that they would never mention the event again, either in public or in private. Suicide as the cause of death was at one time also listed on the mountain meadows associa tion web site with no documentation to back it up if suicide cannot be proven it is never listed as a cause of death. Mountain meadows massacre page 2 legends of america. The first was the seminal work by juanita brooks the mountain meadows massacre in 2016. The 26th annual lecture revisiting the massacre at. The mountain meadows massacre was one of the worst acts of premeditated mass murder ever committed by americans against other americans. Revisiting the massacre at mountain meadows dixie state. Massacre at mountain meadows this is the second book about moutain meadows massacre ive read. Jul 11, 2015 the truth about mountain meadows, utah. Part ii, the dilemma of blame, salt lake tribune, march 14, 2000 that which we have done here building a monument to victims of the m. Lee was later convicted as a mass murderer for his complicity in the mountain meadows massacre, sentenced to death and was executed in 1877.
Scholars are praising a new book that offers an indepth look at one of the. The attacks began on september 7 and culminated on september 11, 1857, resulting in the mass slaughter of most in the emigrant party by members of the utah territorial militia from the iron county district, together with some southern paiute native americans. Massacre at mountain meadows is a book by latterday saint historian richard e. Mountain meadows massacre mormonism, the mormon church. On september 10th, 1999, the remains recovered from that grave were reinterred in a burial vault inside the new wall, along with some soil from arkansas, during a private ceremony. Revisiting the massacre at mountain meadows 3 that to have this history both advocate and defend this new dispensation, it must be kept honest and fearless and full as well when the tide of events were not favorable for the church and also when the tides seemed to run against it. Her work was acclaimed by historians, however, leading to her recognition as an exemplary. It occurred in southern utah between cedar city and st.
To everyones surprise, it scooped up the bones of 28 massacre victims, and with it unearthed a new controversy see mountain meadows massacre, november 30, 1999. She writes, the church leaders decided to sacrifice lee. Although the mountain meadows massacre was covered to some extent in the media during the 1850s, citation needed its first period of intense nationwide publicity began around 1872. The mountain meadows massacre is something most people have probably never heard of before unless youre a mormon or had ancestors who were part of the massacred fancher wagon party. The aftermath of mountain meadows history smithsonian. Jun 25, 2009 using new archival research, walker, turley, and leonard strive to accurately represent the historical context surrounding the mountain meadows massacre. The book provided an important history of early mormonism as well as offering lees somewhat selfserving account of the events leading to the mountain meadows massacre. Book provides an unflinching look at mountain meadows massacre. Program on the massacre at mountainmeadows, 4 august 2008 kuer. The mountain meadows massacre was a mass slaughter of the fancherbaker emigrant wagon train at mountain meadows, utah territory, by a local mormon militia and members of the paiute indian tribe on september 11, 1857. This book was the first to seriously attempt an honest investigation of the massacre, unflinchingly seeking the truth.
The mountain meadows massacre stands without a parallel amongst the crimes that stain the pages of american history. A scholarly look at the disastrous mountain meadows massacre. Mountain meadows massacre descendants this site is. The conversation about mountain meadows is not really about mountain meadows at all. The mountain meadows massacre was the first work to fully document mormon involvement in the massacre. The massacre has been portrayed in several plays, and in a 2007 motion picture, september dawn. John doyle lee september 6, 1812 march 23, 1877 was an american pioneer and prominent early member of the latter day saint movement in utah. He is the recipient of the 2017 genealogyhistory achievement award from the american library association. Produced in cooperation with the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church, it. Lee, the only militiaman executed, was effectively a scapegoat.
Among the materials they found were two major collections known but largely. The controversy over the mountain meadows massacre is emblematic of the mormons difficulty in dealing with the complexities of their own past. A resulting book published by oxford university press in 2008 by authors ronald w. Mountain meadows massacre and mormon theology wikipedia. The mountain meadows massacre, ensign, sep 2007, 1421 this month marks the 150th anniversary of a terrible episode in the history of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. The mountain meadows massacre 1950 by juanita brooks was the first definitive study of the mountain meadows massacre. Congress to accord utah territorial status, which was granted.
The mountain meadows massacre of 1857 and the trials of. Mountain meadows massacre memorial veyo, utah atlas. Review of definitive new book, massacre at mountain meadows, august, 2008. Produced in cooperation with the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church, it is the. Marker placed at fancher grave site there is no documented proof of suicide by christopher kit carson fancher as claimed by the article on the bchrs web site. Captain john jacktwitty baker lead a wagon train of arkansas immigrants to california in 1857. Gene sessions, mountain meadows association on august 3rd, 1999, workers excavating for the wall around the new monument accidently uncovered the 1859 carleton grave. The new book, massacre at mountain meadows, published by oxford. Records, history, monuments, information and links on the september 11, 1857 massacre at mountain meadows of more than 120 arkansas emigrants while traveling through utah on their way to california. Drawn from documents previously not available to scholars and a careful rereading of traditional sources, this gripping narrative offers fascinating new insight into why mormons settlers in isolated southern utah deceived the emigrant party. In the fall of 1857, some 120 californiabound emigrants were killed in lonely mountain meadows in southern utah. As historian will bagley noted, lee reconstructed his chronology to distance himself from the initial attack and provided blistering attacks on the men who testified against him. But in the aftermath of the massacre, only one participant was.
The book is meticulously documented, with 127 pages of endnotes. A very sad book of the deaths of so many people at the mountain meadows massacre. The leader of the wagon train was my 3rd great uncle alexander fancher. An american tragedy, is to date the most thorough account of the massacre and the events leading up to it. An american tragedy oxford university press, 2008, they discovered several oral interviews, written statements, and letters from some of those participants. The mountain meadows massacre is one of the most controversial moments in utah history. The mountain meadows massacre occurred on friday, september 11, 1857 in mountain meadows, utah, several miles south of enterprise in washington county along the old spanish trail. The mountain meadows massacre 1950 by juanita brooks was the first definitive study of the mountain meadows massacre juanita brooks, a mormon historian trained in historical methods, was discouraged from studying the incident, and she suffered some ostracism from fellow mormons after its publication. It was produced by eric young with dave chase, jan walker and larinda wenzel and distributed through the studio, inc. Book provides an unflinching look at mountain meadows massacre copied to clipboard scholars are praising a new book that offers an indepth look at one of the greatest tragedies in the history of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. The mountain meadows massacre by juanita brooks, paperback. Much of the evidence used in the book was available to other historiansthe church archives had not previously withheld as.
On september 11, 1857, some 50 to 60 local militiamen in southern utah, aided by american indian allies, massacred about 120 emigrants who were traveling. The ancient paths 7th interview with lds historian sandra tanner on the mountain meadows massacre duration. Mountain meadows massacre 1857 massacre frank kirkmans. The victims of the massacre, known as the bakerfancher party, were passing through the utah territory to california in 1857. I was amazed to see the event took place on 9111857. This book was the first to seriously attempt an honest investigation.
A new book, massacre at mountain meadows, tries to explain what happened that day and why. Two days after the massacre, brigham youngs messenger finally arrived at mountain meadows with the orders to let the wagon train pass. The attacks culminated on september 11, 1857 in the mass slaughter of the emigrant party by the iron county district of the utah territorial militia and some local indians. Leonard were researching their book massacre at mountain meadows. The aftermath of mountain meadows the massacre almost brought the united states to war against the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, but only one man was brought to trial. Pages in category mountain meadows massacre the following 35 pages are in this category, out of 35 total. Leonard and their colleagues uncovered a great deal of information about the 1857 massacre, leading to a clearer understanding of how this tragedy happened.
Discover mountain meadows massacre memorial in veyo, utah. As part of youngs vision of a premillennial kingdom of god. It was produced by eric young with dave chase, jan walker and. The mountain meadows massacre was a series of attacks on the bakerfancher emigrant wagon train at mountain meadows in southern utah. A stoic rock cairn is all that remains to remember one of the more brutal instances of frontier treachery in american history. During years of research for their 2008 book massacre at mountain meadows. Some mormons, who previously had been victimized by the. This mountain meadows massacre is brought to you for free and open access by the all journals at. This one was published in 2008 so, 58 years later by ronald walker a mormon historian in slc. Christopher kit carson fancher mountain meadows massacre. Mountain meadows massacre the mountain meadows massacre stands without a parallel amongst the crimes that stain the pages of american history. Legacy of the mountain meadows massacre 2004 and the mountain meadows massacre 2001. Although many historians and organizations have weighed in with evidence and opinions on one side or another, we may never. Mountain meadows massacre 1857 massacre frank kirkman.
Changing narratives of the mountain meadows massacre in utahs. This was after investigators obtained the confession of philip klingensmith, a mormon bishop at the time of the massacre and a private in the utah militia. Drawn from documents previously not available to scholars and a careful rereading of traditional sources, this gripping narrative offers fascinating new insight into why mormon settlers in isolated southern utah deceived an emigrant party with a promise of safety and then killed the adults. The attacks culminated on september 11, 1857 in the mass slaughter of the emigrant party by the iron county district of the utah territorial militia and some local indians initially intended to be an indian massacre, two men with leadership roles in local. Massacre at mountain meadows offers the most thoroughly researched account of the massacre ever written. This, in some ways, is just the latest in a long line of books many of them quite recent written on the mountain meadows massacre of 1857. After reading michael richan on the event in one of his river books i had to read the true story on the event. Read about our visit to the site of the mountain meadows massacre.
For the decade prior the emigrants arrival, utah territory had existed as a theocracy led by brigham young. Killings and aftermath of the mountain meadows massacre. It was a crime committed without cause or justification of any kind to relieve it of its fearful character. This is the main, albeit unspoken, engine that drives bagleys work and the work of walker, turley, and leonard. Largest collection of records and information on the mountain meadows massacre on the internet. Carleton, special report on the mountain meadows massacre. The mountain meadows massacre is a 2001 documentary film about the mountain meadows massacre. It was a crime committed without cause or justification of any kind to relieve it of its fearful character when nearly exhausted from fatigue and thirst, the men of the caravan were approached by white men, with a flag of. The mountain meadows massacre was a series of attacks on the bakerfancher emigrant wagon train, at mountain meadows in southern utah. Only 17 children were allowed to liveall under the age of 7. The leaders of the mormon church also counseled silence. The mountain meadows massacre is widely considered to be the most violent and. Leonard was also the director of the museum of church history and art in salt lake city, utah.
Baker reportedly found nothing relating to the massacre, clearing the way for the construction of the new monument. From the beginning, accounts have been confused and muddled about why it happened, who ordered it, and what might have provoked it. The victims of the massacre were from arkansas and were members of the fancher wagon train. On august 3, 1999, a backhoe began digging the foundation. It is about the nature, character, and viability of the lds church. In the book, brooks demonstrated convincingly that the mormon militia was responsible for the massacre, and that john d. The book is a mustread for scholars of the mountain meadows massacre and lds. Review of massacre at mountain meadows, in western american literature, spring 2009. Mormon theology has long been thought to be one of the causes of the mountain meadows massacre. The mountain meadows massacre ensign article by richard e. The book concerns the 1857 mountain meadows massacre in southern utah, and is the latest study of the subject.
While visiting the utah shakespearean festival, jill and i left the drama and tragedies behind for a morning to visit a site of much greater drama and tragedy. The incident began as an attack, quickly turned into a siege, and eventually culminated in the murder of. Accord ing to peter shirts, that higher estimate included some indians recruited the day. Mountain meadows massacre memorial veyo, utah atlas obscura. The mountain meadows massacre descendants site is dedicated in loving memory to our ancestors who died in the massacre at mountain meadows, utah september 711th, 1857. Leonardfor their book, massacre at mountain meadows, published in 2008. This church had its beginnings in western new york during the revivalist period of the early 1800s, when preachers stirred whole counties into frenzy with their lurid eloquence, and sporadic sects sprang up over the. The massacre has also been of subject of several film documentaries including, burying the past. The aftermath of mountain meadows history smithsonian magazine. In september 1857, a wagon train passing through utah laden with gold was attacked.
874 12 1040 1513 1370 205 1050 1577 529 841 1218 1634 1504 1001 926 388 666 1106 1436 259 1028 1042 1400 541 1594 689 257 1332 684 1005 612 1620 664 595 754 1183 722 1203 983